What is Ludonarrative Dissonance?

Ludonarrative dissonance is a conflict between a game’s narrative (story, tone, themes) and its gameplay (mechanics, systems, player behavior). It happens when what the game says clashes with what it lets — or forces — the player to do.

It’s the moment when the story says one thing, but the gameplay tells another — and the player feels the gap.

1️⃣ Definition

Component	Meaning
Ludo	Gameplay (from Latin ludus = play)
Narrative	Story, world, tone, character arcs
Dissonance	A clash or contradiction between the two

📍Dissonance isn’t always bad — but if it’s unintentional, it breaks trust.

2️⃣ Why It Matters

Impact	Result
Breaks immersion	Player stops believing in the character or world
Undermines emotion	Story says “serious,” gameplay says “power fantasy”
Hurts credibility	Especially in morally grounded or story-heavy games
Reveals shallow systems	Player choices don’t match the narrative weight assigned to them

📍If the player says “Why would I do that?” — you’ve hit dissonance.

3️⃣ Classic Examples

Game	Dissonance
Uncharted	Nathan Drake is a charming rogue in cutscenes… and a mass killer in gameplay
Tomb Raider (2013)	Lara is devastated after her first kill… then becomes a headshot machine
BioShock	Critiques obedience — but gives you no real choice until the ending
Red Dead Redemption 2	Arthur reflects on morality… while you freely rob, kill, and hunt wildlife between missions

📍Dissonance is most damaging when the game tries to be sincere — but can’t back it up systemically.

4️⃣ Root Causes of Dissonance

Source	Example
Tone mismatch	Grim narrative + cartoonish ragdoll deaths
Moral inconsistency	Hero hates killing but gets a killstreak bonus
Reward structure contradiction	Game rewards looting innocents while scolding you in dialogue
Player agency mismatch	“Your choices matter” — but they don’t change the outcome

📍Narrative isn't just cutscenes. It's what your systems reward.

5️⃣ How to Avoid or Use Dissonance Intentionally

Strategy	Example
Align verbs with character	A pacifist story needs non-lethal mechanics (e.g. Undertale)
Design systemic narrative	Let actions shape outcomes (Disco Elysium, Papers, Please)
Write to the mechanic	If combat is core, don’t pretend the protagonist is peaceful
Embrace dissonance	Use it for critique (Spec Ops: The Line, The Stanley Parable)
Minimize friction	Keep feedback, rewards, and tone consistent with theme

📍Every core mechanic is a narrative act. If the verbs betray the story, the player feels it.

‣

…

6️⃣ Related Concepts

Term	Meaning
Ludonarrative harmony	When story and gameplay reinforce each other (Journey, Celeste)
Environmental storytelling	Letting the world speak without exposition
Player authorship	Story shaped by play, not imposed from outside

📍Ludonarrative harmony doesn’t mean no tension — it means intentional alignment.

✅ Dissonance Design Checklist

Do the mechanics support the story’s tone and themes?

Is the character’s voice reflected in the player’s verbs?

Are reward systems reinforcing — or contradicting — moral framing?

Is dissonance acknowledged (narratively or systemically), or ignored?

Would removing the cutscenes make the gameplay feel completely different?

📍Don’t avoid dissonance. Understand it. Then decide if it serves your game.

Summary

Term	Ludonarrative Dissonance
What it is	A conflict between what a game’s story says and what its systems encourage
Why it matters	Breaks immersion, emotion, and credibility if not intentional
Where it appears	Tone shifts, moral disconnects, player agency mismatches
Design goal	Align systems and narrative — or use dissonance as a theme with purpose

📍When gameplay and story don’t speak the same truth, the player hears the silence between them — and that’s where trust is lost.